<?xml version="1.0"?>
<document>
	<!-- 
		
		Warning: do not use any auto-format function on this file.
		Since "source" divs use pre as white-space, it affects the
		look of the code parts in this document.
		
	-->
<body>
		<h2>Chapter 3: Logback configuration with Joran</h2>
		<div class="author">
			Authors: Ceki G&#252;lc&#252;, S&#233;bastien Pennec
		</div>

<p>Joran stands for a cold north-west wind which, every now and then,
blows force-fully on Lake Leman, a.k.a lake Geneva. Located right in
the middle of Europe, the Leman happens to be the continent's largest
sweet water reserve.
</p>

<h2>Introduction</h2>

<p>For it's configuration, logback relies on Joran, a
mature, flexible and powerful configuration framework. Many of the
capabilities offered by logback modules are possible thanks to Joran.
</p>

<p>Joran is actually a generic configuration system which can be used
independently of logging. To emphaises this point, we should mention
that the logback-core module does not have a notion of loggers. In
that sprit, many of the examples related to this tutorial, have
nothing to do with loggers, appenders or layouts.
</p>

<p>The examples for this tutorial can be found under
<em>LOGBACK_HOME/logback-examples/src/main/java/chapter3</em>.
</p>

<p>To install joran, simply <a href="download.html">download</a> 
logback and add <em>logback-core-VERSION.jar</em> to your classpath.</p>

<h2>Historical perspective</h2>

<p>One of the most powerful features of the Java language is
reflection. Reflection makes it possible to configure software systems
declaratively. For example, many important properties of an EJB are
configured with the <em>ejb.xml</em> file. While EJBs are written in Java, many
of their properties are specified within the <em>ejb.xml</em> file. Similarly,
logback settings can be specified in a configuration file, expressed
in XML format.
</p>

<p>In log4j, logback's predecessor, <code>DOMConfigurator</code> that
shipped with log4j version 1.2.x can parse configuration files written
in XML. The <code>DOMConfigurator</code> was written in a way that
forced to tweak it each time the structure of the configuration file
changed. The modified code had to be recompiled and redeployed. Just
as importantly, the code of the DOMConfigurator consists of loops
dealing with children elements containing many interspersed if/else
statements. One could not help but notice that that particular code
reeked of redundancy.  The <a
href="http://jakarta.apache.org/commons/digester/">digester
project</a> has shown that it is possible to parse XML files using
pattern matching rules. At parse time, digester will apply the rules
that match previously stated patterns. Rule classes are usually quite
small and specialized. Consequently, they are relatively easy to
understand and to maintain.
</p>

<p>Joran is heavily inspired by the commons-digester project but uses
a slightly different terminology. In commons-digester, a rule can be
seen as consisting of a pattern and a rule, as shown by the
<code>Digester.addRule(String pattern, Rule rule)</code> method. We
find it unnecessarily confusing to have a rule to consist of itself,
not recursively but with a different meaning. In Joran, a rule
consists of a pattern and an action. An action is invoked when a match
occurs for the corresponding pattern. This relation between patterns
and actions lies at the core of Joran.  Quite remarkably, one can deal
with quite complex requirements by using simple patterns, or more
precisely with exact matches and wildcard matches. For example, the
pattern "a/b" will match a <code>&lt;b></code> element nested within
an <code>&lt;a></code> element but not a <code>&lt;c></code> element,
even if nested within a <code>&lt;b></code> element. It is also
possible to match a particular XML element, regardless of its nesting
level, by using the "*" wildcard character. For example, the pattern
"*/a" will match an <code>&lt;a></code> element at any nesting
position within the document. Other types of patterns, for example
"a/*", are not currently supported by Joran.
</p>

<h2>SAX or DOM?</h2>

<p>Due to the event-based architecture of the SAX API, a tool based on
SAX cannot easily deal with forward references, that is, references to
elements which are defined later than the current element being
processed. Elements with cyclical references are equally
problematic. More generally, the DOM API allows the user to perform
searches on all the elements and make forward jumps.
</p>

<p>This extra flexibility initially led us to choose the DOM API as
the underlying parsing API for Joran. After some experimentation, it
quickly became clear that dealing with jumps to distant elements while
parsing the DOM tree did not make sense when the interpretation rules
were expressed in the form of patterns and actions. <em>Joran only
needs to be given the elements in the XML document in a sequential,
depth-first order.</em>
</p>

<p>Joran was first implemented in DOM. However, the author migrated to
SAX in order to benefit form the location information provided to the
user, that is, to an <code>org.w3.sax.ContentHandler</code>. With the
help of location information, it becomes possible to display essential
error reports to the user which include exact line and column. This
extra information turns out to be handy in hunting down problems.
</p>


<h2>Actions</h2>

<p>Actions extend the
<code>ch.qos.logback.core.joran.action.Action</code> class which
consists of the following abstract methods.
</p>


<div class="source"><pre>package ch.qos.logback.core.joran.action;

import org.xml.sax.Attributes;
import ch.qos.logback.core.joran.spi.ExecutionContext;

public abstract class Action {
  

 /**
  * Called when the parser first encounters an element.
  */
  public abstract void begin(ExecutionContext ec, 
                             String name, 
                             Attributes attributes);

 /**
  * Called when the parser encounters the element end. At 
  * this stage, we can assume that child elements, if any,
  * have been processed. 
  */
  public abstract void end(ExecutionContext ec, String name);
}</pre></div>

<p>Thus, every action must implement the begin and end methods.</p>


<h2>Execution context</h2>

<p>To allow various actions to collaborate, the invocation of begin
and end methods include an execution context as the first
parameter. The execution context includes an object stack, an object
map, an error list and a reference to the Joran interpreter invoking
the action. Please see the
<code>ch.qos.logback.core.joran.spi.ExecutionContext</code> class for
the exact list of fields contained in the execution context.
</p>

<p>Actions can collaborate together by fetching, pushing or popping
objects from the common object stack, or by putting and fetching keyed
objects on the common object map. Actions can report any error
conditions by adding error items on the execution context's
<code>StatusManager</code>.
</p>

<a name="helloWorld" />
<h3>A hello world example</h3>

<p>The <em>logback-examples/src/main/java/joran/helloWorld/</em> directory includes a
trivial action and Joran interpreter setup which just diaplays "Hello
World" when a &lt;hello-world&gt; element is encountered in an XML file.
It also includes the basic steps which are
necessary to set up and invoke a Joran interpreter.
</p>
<p>
The <em>hello.xml</em> file contains only one element, without any
other nested elements. The <code>HelloWorldAction</code> class is 
a trivial implementation: it only prints "Hello World" in the console when
it's <code>begin()</code> method is called.
</p>
<p>
<code>HelloWorld</code> is a class that sets up the Joran interpreter,
with the minimal steps necessary:
</p>

<ul>
	<!-- Pretty dirty, thanks site-generation... -->
	<p>It creates a <code>RuleStore</code> and a <code>Context</code></p>
	<p>It adds the <em>hello-world</em> pattern, with it's corresponding action</p>
	<p>It creates a Joran interpreter, and passes the <code>RuleStore</code></p>
	<p>It creates a SAX parser and parses the given file, specifying the newly created
	Joran interpreter as the <code>ContentHandler</code></p>
</ul>

<p>
It's last step is to print the content of the <code>Context</code>. 
Since Joran uses logback's powerfull <code>Status</code> objects for 
error reporting, one can have a good feedback on  what happened during 
the parsing.
</p>

<p>
In this example, the parsing is rather simple. The <em>hello-world</em> element 
will activate <code>HelloWorldAction</code>'s <code>begin()</code> and 
<code>end()</code> methods.
In the first method, a simple call to <code>System.out.println()</code> 
will be issued, displaying "Hello World" in the console.
</p>

<a name="calculator" />
<h3>Collaborating actions</h3>
<p>
The logback-examples/src/main/java/joran/calculator/ directory includes several actions
which collaborate together through the common object stack in order
to accomplish simple computations.
</p>
<p>
The <em>calculator1.xml</em> file contains a <code>computation</code> element, 
with a nested <code>literal</code> element.
</p>
<p>
In the <code>Calculator1</code> class, we declare various patterns and actions,
that will collaborate and calculate a result based on the xml file. The simple
<em>calculator1.xml</em> file only creates a computation and declares a literal
value. The resulting parsing is pretty simple:
</p>
<ul>
	<p>The <code>ComputationAction1</code> class' <code>begin()</code> method
	is called</p>
	<p>The <code>LiteralAction</code> class' <code>begin()</code> and <code>end()</code> 
	methods are called</p>
	<p>The <code>ComputationAction1</code> class' <code>end()</code> method
	is called</p>
</ul>
<p>
What is interesting here is the way that the Actions collaborate.
The <code>LiteralAction</code> reads a literal value and pushes it in the
object stack maintained by the <code>ExecutionContext</code>. Once done,
any other action can pop the value to read or modify it. Here, the
<code>end()</code> method of the <code>ComputationAction1</code> class pops
the value from the stack and prints it.
</p>
<p>The <em>calculator2.xml</em> file is a bit more complex, and much more interesting.</p>
<p>It contains the following elements:</p>
<div class="source"><pre>&lt;computation name="toto"&gt;
  &lt;literal value="7"/&gt;
  &lt;literal value="3"/&gt;
  &lt;add/&gt;
  &lt;literal value="3"/&gt;
  &lt;multiply/&gt;
&lt;/computation&gt;</pre></div>
<p>
Here, there are obviously more actions that will be part of the computation.
</p>
<p>When called, the <code>AddAction</code> class will remove the two integers at
the bottom of the stack, add them and push the resulting integer at the
top of the stack, for further use.</p>
<p>Later in the computation, the <code>MultiplyAction</code> class will be called.
It will take the last two integers from the stack, multiply them and
push the result in the stack.</p>
<p>We have here two examples of action whose <code>begin()</code> method behaves in 
a certain, predictable way, but whose <code>end()</code> methods are empty.</p>

<p>Finally, a <em>calculator3.xml</em> is also provided, to demonstrate the possibility
elements that contain instances of the same element. Here's the content of
<em>calculator3.xml</em>:</p>
<div class="source"><pre>&lt;computation name="toto"&gt;
  &lt;computation&gt;
    &lt;literal value="7"/&gt;
    &lt;literal value="3"/&gt;
    &lt;add/&gt;
  &lt;/computation&gt;   
 
  &lt;literal value="3"/&gt;
  &lt;multiply/&gt;
&lt;/computation&gt;</pre></div>

<p>Much like the use of parentheses in an algebrical equation, the presence of
a <code>computation</code> element nested in another is managed by the 
<code>ComputationAction2</code> class using an internal stack. The well-formedness 
of XML will guarantee that a value saved by one begin() will be consumed 
only by the matching end() method.</p>

<a name="newRule" />
<h3>New-rule action</h3>
<p>Joran includes an action which allows the Joran interpreter to lean
new rules on the fly while interpreting the XML file containing the
new rules.  See the <em>logback-examples/src/main/java/joran/newRule/</em>
directory for sample code.
</p>
<p>In this package, the <code>NewRuleCalculator</code> class contains 
the same setup as we have seen so far, but for one line:</p>

<source>ruleStore.addRule(new Pattern("/computation/new-rule"), new NewRuleAction());</source>

<p>By adding this line, we ask Joran to allow new rules to be learnt
at parsing time. It works pretty much like the other rules: it has a
<code>begin()</code> and <code>end()</code> method, and is called each time
the parser finds a <em>new-rule</em> element.</p>

<p>When called, the <code>begin()</code> method looks for a <em>pattern</em>
and a <em>actionClass</em> attribute. The action class is then instanciated
and added to the <code>RuleStore</code>, along with its corresponding pattern.</p>

<p>Here is how new rules can be declared in an xml file:</p>

<div class="source"><pre>&lt;new-rule pattern="*/computation/literal" actionClass="joran.calculator.LiteralAction"/&gt;</pre></div>

<p>Using new rule declarations, the preceding example, involving the calculation, could be
expressed this way:</p>

<div class="source"><pre>&lt;computation name="toto"&gt;
  &lt;new-rule pattern="*/computation/literal" 
            actionClass="joran.calculator.LiteralAction"/&gt;
  &lt;new-rule pattern="*/computation/add" 
            actionClass="joran.calculator.AddAction"/&gt;
  &lt;new-rule pattern="*/computation/multiply" 
            actionClass="joran.calculator.MultiplyAction"/&gt;

  &lt;computation&gt;
    &lt;literal value="7"/&gt;
    &lt;literal value="3"/&gt;
    &lt;add/&gt;
  &lt;/computation&gt;   
 
  &lt;literal value="3"/&gt;
  &lt;multiply/&gt;
&lt;/computation&gt;</pre></div>

<a name="implicit" />
<h3>Implicit actions </h3>
<p>The rules defined thus far are called explicit rules because they
require an explicit pattern, hence fixing the tag name of the elements
for which they apply.
</p>

<p>In highly extensible systems, the number and type of components to
handle are innumerable so that it would become very tedious or even
impossible to list all the applicable patterns by name.
</p>

<p>At the same time, even in highly extensible systems one can observe
well-defined patterns linking the various parts together. Implicit
rules come in very handy when processing components composed of
sub-components unknown ahead of time. For example, Apache Ant is
capable of handling tasks which contain tags unknown at compile time
by looking at methods whose names start with add, as in addFile, or
addClassPath.  When Ant encounters an embedded tag within a task, it
simply instantiates an object that matches the signature of the task
class' add method and attaches the resulting object to the parent.
</p>

<p>Joran includes similar capability in the form of implicit
actions. Joran keeps a list of implicit actions which can be applied
if no explicit pattern matches the current XML element.  However,
applying an implicit action may not be always appropriate. Before
executing the implicit action, Joran asks an implicit action whether
it is appropriate in the current context. Only if the action replies
affirmatively does Joran interpreter invoke the (implicit)
action. This extra step makes it possible to support multiple implicit
actions or obviously none, if no implicit action is appropriate for a
given situation.
</p>

<p>For example, the NestedComponentIA extending ImplicitAction , will
instantiate the class specified in a nested component and attach it
to the parent component by using setter method of the parent
component and the nested element's name. Under certain circumstances,
a nested action needs to be applied to an element say &lt;a> and also
to another element &lt;b> nested within &lt;a>. The current
implementation of <code>NestedComponentIA</code> is capable of
handling multiply nested elements requiring intervention by the same
implicit action.
</p>

<p>Both ImplicitAction and NestedComponentIA are located in the
<code>ch.qos.logback.core.joran.action</code> package.
</p>

<p>Refer to the <em>logback-examples/src/main/java/joran/implicit</em>
directory for an example of an implicit action.
</p>

<p>In that directory, you will find two actions classes, one xml file and one
class containing the setup of Joran.</p>

<p>The <code>NOPAction</code> class does nothing. It is used to set
the context of the <em>foo</em> element, using this line:</p>

<source>ruleStore.addRule(new Pattern("*/foo"), new NOPAction());</source>

<p>After that, the implicit action, namely <code>PrintMeImplicitAction</code>, 
is added to the <code>RuleStore</code>. This is done by simply adding a new
instance of the action to the <code>Joran interpreter</code></p>

<source>ji.addImplicitAction(new PrintMeImplicitAction());</source>

<p>When called, the <code>isApplicable()</code> method of <code>PrintMeImplicitAction</code>
checks the value of the <em>printme</em> attribute. If the value is <code>true</code>, 
the implicit action is applicable: its <code>begin()</code> method will be called.</p>

<p>The <em>implicit1.xml</em> file contains the following lines:</p>

<div class="source"><pre>&lt;foo&gt;

  &lt;xyz printme="true"&gt;
    &lt;abc printme="true"/&gt;
  &lt;/xyz&gt;

  &lt;xyz/&gt;

  &lt;foo printme="true"/&gt;

&lt;/foo&gt;</pre></div>

<p>As one can see, the first element will be printed, since it has a <em>printme</em>
attribute, which bears the value <code>true</code>.</p>

<p>The second element will not be printed, because no <em>printme</em> attibute is present.</p>

<p>The last element will not be printed, although the required attribute is present.
This is because implicit rules are called only if no explicit rules are defined. Since
we added a <code>NOPAction</code> with the <em>*/foo</em> pattern, it will be used instead
of the <code>PrintMeImplicitAction</code>.</p>

<p>Running the example yields the following output:</p>

<div class="source"><pre>Element &lt;xyz> asked to be printed.
Element &lt;abc> asked to be printed.
ERROR in ch.qos.logback.core.joran.spi.ExecutionContext@1c5c1 - no applicable action \
for &lt;xyz>, current pattern is [/foo/xyz]</pre></div>

<p>The last line was printed because of a call to <code>StatusPrinter</code> at the end
of the main class.</p>

<h3>Non goals</h3>

<p>The Joran API is not intended to be used to parse documents with
thousands of elements.
</p>

</body>
</document>